Problem 1
problem id: 150_0
Comprehensive explanations of the expanding Universe often use the balloon analogy. Although the balloon analogy is useful, one must guard against misconceptions that it can generate. Point out the misconceptions that appear when using this analogy [see M.O. Farooq, Observational constraints on dark energy cosmological model parameters, arXiv: 1309.3710.]
(a) The surface that is expanding is two dimensional; the "center" of the balloon is in the third dimension and is not part of the surface, which has no center.
(b) The balloon is expanded by the pressure difference between the inside and the outside, but the Universe is not being expanded by pressure.
(c) Pressure couples to gravity in the Einstein equation, so the addition of (positive) pressure to the Universe would slow, not increase, the expansion rate. It is the negative pressure which is only capable to generate the accelerated expansion of the Universe.
(d) If the dots on the balloon represent galaxies, they too will expand. But real galaxies do not expand due to general Hubble expansion because they are gravitationally bound objects. We can make a better analogy by gluing solid objects (like 10 cent coins) to the surface of the balloon to represent galaxies, so that they do not expand when the balloon expands.